Arbitration
Hong Kong Court extends anti-suit injunctions to related but non-parties to the Hong Kong arbitration agreement
A and Others v Z [2026] HKCFI 5453
In this decision, A, B, C and D (together, the “Plaintiffs”) applied to the Hong Kong Court for an anti-suit injunction against a Mainland company (Z) to stop it from pursuing a series of lawsuits in the Mainland courts, because those lawsuits concerned disputes that the parties had agreed to resolve by arbitration in Hong Kong. The Hong Kong Court of First Instance granted the injunctions as sought, “until further orders of the Court or of the tribunal”.
Fact
The parties and the contracts concerned
A is a Singapore company within a US-based glass-substrate group (the “Group”). B represents the Group’s China headquarters, and C and D are Group companies that produce glass substrates. Z is a Mainland glass-substrate manufacturer.
In 2017 and 2018, A and Z signed two joint venture agreements (the “JV Agreements”) to set up joint ventures in Xianyang and Chengdu. A key feature was an exclusive supply arrangement: the joint ventures would buy certain materials and services only from Group companies, while Z had to arrange for its affiliates to buy LCD glass substrates from the joint ventures.
The JV Agreements were governed by PRC law, but stated that all disputes “arising from or in connection with” them would be resolved by arbitration in Hong Kong administered by the Hong Kong International Arbitration Centre (HKIAC). Importantly, only A and Z signed the JV Agreements; B, C and D did not.
The mainland lawsuits
From August 2025, Z commenced several legal proceedings in the Mainland courts, all concerning the exclusive supply arrangement:
1. A “derivative” claim against A, C and D, brought by Z on behalf of the Xianyang joint venture, alleging that Group companies had harmed the joint venture (for example, by overcharging for supplies), and claiming RMB300 million.
2. Unfair competition claims against B and C, alleging that the Group abused its market position to stop customers buying Z’s products.
3. Claims against A to declare the arbitration agreements invalid, alleging duress, breach of public policy and that the disputes fell outside the clause.
Roles of the Hong Kong Court
Although the joint ventures operated in the Mainland and the JV Agreements were governed by PRC law, A and Z had chosen Hong Kong as the “seat” ( legal home) of their arbitration. After Z commenced the Mainland proceedings, the Plaintiffs applied to the Hong Kong Court for an “anti-suit injunction” requiring Z to withdraw those proceedings and restraining it from pursuing them, on the basis that they circumvented the agreed arbitration process.
In considering the Plaintiff’s application, the Court explained that, by agreeing to arbitrate in Hong Kong, A and Z had also agreed to submit to the supervisory jurisdiction of the Hong Kong courts. The choice of PRC law to govern the JV Agreements did not displace that supervisory role. The Court was not being asked to determine the merits of the underlying business dispute, but whether the Mainland proceedings should be restrained to protect the parties’ agreement to arbitrate and allow the tribunal to determine its jurisdiction first.
Issues
1. How strong must the Plaintiffs’ case be?
Z argued that, because the order would effectively end its Mainland cases, the Plaintiffs had to prove the arbitration agreement covered the disputes to a high degree of probability. The Plaintiffs said they only needed to show a prima facie case.
2. Can the arbitration clause protect companies that have never signed the contract?
B, C and D never signed the JV Agreements, so the arbitration clause in those agreements does not bind them. Does that mean Z is free to sue the non-signatory parties (B, C and D) in the Mainland courts, rather than taking those disputes to arbitration?
3. Can the same dispute escape arbitration just by giving it a different label?
Z argued that its derivative claim was brought on behalf of the joint venture rather than in Z’s own right under the JV Agreements, and that its unfair competition claims were statutory claims rather than contractual claims, so neither type fell within the arbitration clause.
4. Which forum decides whether the arbitration agreement is valid?
Z had asked a Mainland court to declare the arbitration agreements invalid, alleging that it had been duressed into signing the JV Agreements without any real contractual intention.
Ruling
1. A prima facie case is enough on the arbitration and jurisdiction issues. The Court applied the lower prima facie standard, the same test used when the Hong Kong court pauses its own proceedings in favour of arbitration. It would be odd to demand more to stop proceedings abroad than at home. The Court also stressed that it was not making a final ruling. Its role on this application was only that of a “filter”: to check that there was a prima facie case that the dispute belonged in arbitration and, if so, to send the parties down that path. If the tribunal later rules that it has no jurisdiction, and that ruling survives review by the Hong Kong Court, Z is free to return to the Mainland courts.
The Court’s treatment of the unfair-competition claims illustrates this approach. Z’s experts relied on a Mainland case excluding anti-monopoly claims from arbitration, but the case did not establish that unfair competition claims were also excluded. However, the Court preferred the Plaintiffs’ expert evidence, which distinguished unfair-competition claims from anti-monopoly claims and identified at least one Mainland decision allowing such claims to be arbitrated. The Court therefore found at least a prima facie case that the unfair-competition claims were arbitrable. Taking these matters into account, among other considerations, the Court granted the injunction, leaving the tribunal to decide the issue first.
2. Adding non-signatory defendants did not help Z. The Court accepted that the arbitration agreement was only between A and Z , and that B, C and D were not parties to it. However, the Court held that Z’s promise to arbitrate was not limited to claims against A. It also prevented Z from suing A’s group companies in court over closely connected claims that could be pursued against A in arbitration. Otherwise, a party could easily escape an arbitration agreement simply by suing the other side’s related companies instead. Z’s complaints were really about the deal, and it could pursue them against A in arbitration, where A could be ordered to make its affiliates act. Suing the affiliates in the Mainland was a “procedural manoeuvre” to avoid arbitration, and was oppressive.
3. Substance matters more than labels. Z described its Mainland claims as derivative claims and unfair competition claims. However, they all challenged the exclusive supply arrangement under the JV Agreements. The Court therefore found that, whatever their legal labels, the claims arose “from or in connection with” the JV Agreements and fell within the arbitration clause, leaving the tribunal to decide its jurisdiction first.
4. Validity challenges must follow the agreed Hong Kong arbitral process. Z asked the Mainland courts to declare the arbitration agreements invalid. However, by choosing Hong Kong as the place of arbitration, A and Z had also agreed that the Hong Kong courts would supervise the arbitration. Z therefore had to raise its objections with the arbitral tribunal first, with any subsequent court review taking place in Hong Kong, rather than asking the Mainland courts to decide instead. The court expressly noted that the Mainland Court may also have jurisdiction, but the point was that Z had agreed to Hong Kong arbitration and should not invoke another jurisdiction in breach of that agreement.
Comments
A well drafted Hong Kong arbitration clause is a powerful tool: the Hong Kong court will actively protect it against parallel litigation elsewhere, including Mainland lawsuits. Even where the business is run in the Mainland and the contract is governed by PRC law, choosing Hong Kong as the seat of the arbitration allows a party to ask the Hong Kong court to order the other side to drop court proceedings brought in breach of the agreement to arbitrate.
Re-labelling a contract dispute, or suing a counterparty’s group companies instead, will not easily get around a widely drafted arbitration clause. The court looks at what the dispute is really about, and if the complaint can be brought against the contracting party in arbitration, it may treat the claims against group companies as a tactic to avoid arbitration and stop them. As a pro-arbitration jurisdiction, Hong Kong Court favors a more flexible approach in construing and giving effect to an arbitration clause.
